The Voice That Isn't Yours

What a well-witching grandmother taught me about whose voice is actually running my life

There is a grandmother clock in my living room that doesn’t work.

The chimes broke somewhere in transit when it came to me, and it has stood there since, silent and stopped, taking up space in a way that broken things sometimes do when you can’t quite bring yourself to decide what to do with them.

Thanks for reading! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.

It belonged to my great grandmother. And for a long time I told myself I was keeping it because it was probably worth something. Because if someone restored it, brought it back to its original condition, it could have real value. Monetary value. The kind you can point to.

The finish on the wood is amber.

I didn’t notice the irony of that until recently.

My great grandmother was not a woman people fully understood. She married when she was eighteen, had a baby and divorced very shortly after, and then left her young daughter to be raised by her mother, alongside her baby sister who was a few months younger than her own daughter. She went on to own racehorses in California. She ran her own convenience store. She got divorced young in an era when divorce was its own kind of scarlet letter, left West Virginia, built an entirely new life from scratch, and when her daughter graduated high school, she sent for her and brought her back to California.

She witched wells.

Her measurements were maybe 25 inches everywhere, according to a letter she wrote once in her own handwriting - this tiny woman who took up more space in the world than most people twice her size.

She also talked to me about death when I was four years old. Matter of factly, the way she did everything. She’d watched bodies float up out of the ground after flooding in West Virginia when she was young, and she knew what she knew about it, and she didn’t see any reason to pretend otherwise with a small child who was asking real questions.

She was the one who told me it would never be this time again.

I was maybe four or five. We were probably watching Wheel of Fortune or Jeopardy, which we did every evening when she watched me after school. I didn’t understand what she meant. I told her it would be this time again tomorrow - it would be 2:00 again, wouldn’t it?

She just smiled. She knew I’d catch up eventually.

She was planting things in me that I wouldn’t be ready to receive for decades. That’s what the really powerful ones do.

The clock came to me because I always loved it as a child. I always wanted her to make it chime and she would only turn it on occasionally, just for me, like it was a small ceremony she was performing specifically for my benefit.

I have her dressers too. One in my living room, one in my office. They have broken parts. They smell like her house - old, and layered with decades of her cigarette smoke, and something else underneath that I don’t have a word for except her house.

For a while I’ve been thinking about refinishing them. Painting the clock. Taking these amber pieces and making them into something that fits my life now instead of a life that existed fifty years ago in someone else’s house.

And every time I get close to that idea, a voice shows up.

Don’t ruin it. It won’t be worth anything if you do that.

I have heard that voice my whole life. It sounds like wisdom. It sounds like practicality. It sounds like the reasonable thing a reasonable person would say about antiques and preservation and not making decisions you can’t undo.

But here’s what I know now: that voice is not mine.

It belongs to the people who raised me, who were raised by people who survived scarcity, who learned to measure safety in objects and their resale potential because there was a time when that actually mattered. That voice was a survival strategy once. A real one. It kept people okay when okay was genuinely hard to come by.

But it got handed down past its expiration date. And it borrowed the voices of people I love so it would sound like wisdom instead of what it actually is - someone else’s fear, running on autopilot in my nervous system long after the original threat was gone.

This is what conditioning does. It doesn’t announce itself. It doesn’t say I am an inherited belief that no longer serves you. It says don’t ruin it in your mother’s voice and your grandparents’ voices and it sounds so reasonable that you almost miss the moment where you could actually choose something different.

I almost missed it.

Here is what I actually know about that clock:

It is worth maybe a few hundred dollars restored. To a stranger who has none of my history with it.

To me it is priceless and also broken and also amber and also the place where a woman who saw things other people couldn’t see would turn on the chimes occasionally, just for me, like she was letting me in on something.

She is not stored in the finish. The memory lives in me. The smell lives in the wood regardless of what color I paint it. And a woman who reinvented herself completely, multiple times, in an era when women had almost no permission to do that - she is probably the last ancestor who would want me preserving something in amber just because that’s how it started, if she were here today.

I think she’d want it to still be in my life and useful to it.

I think she’d recognize exactly what I’m doing when I strip it down and make it into something that belongs in the life I’m actually living. She did that. Over and over. She took what existed and made it into what it needed to be next.

The value was never in the wood. It was never in the condition or the market price or whether some stranger with a catalog could assign it a number.

It was always in what got transmitted. In the things planted in a small child eating Rollos and watching Jeopardy that would take forty years to fully bloom.

She knew that. She was counting on it.

Here is the thing about the voice that isn’t yours: It feels like protection. It feels like the reasonable, responsible thing. It has borrowed the faces and vocal cords of people you love, which makes it very convincing.

But somewhere underneath it, you already know. You know the difference between wisdom that actually belongs to you and a survival strategy you inherited from someone else’s fear.

You know what you actually want to do with the clock. You know which relationships you’re staying in past their expiration date because don’t ruin it. You know which version of yourself you keep preserved in amber because someone once told you that changing it would make it worth less.

The question isn’t whether you know.

The question is whether you’re ready to listen to what you know instead of the voice that borrowed someone else’s face to sound like wisdom.

It will never be this time again. She told me that when I was four years old and I didn’t understand it yet.

I think I’m finally catching up.